twilight vs harry potter

[falcon678]

kinda but HP7 movie is very loyal to the book

 

[princemaazthefinal]

kinda but HP7 movie is very loyal to the book

true

 

[maybeitwasnoone]

I was dissapointed with some of the Harry Potter movies too anyways, they had edited sooo many parts like someone above said, and added some nonsense in too.
Basically THEY SHOULD NOT MAKE A MOVIE IF THERE'S A STORY WRITTEN ALONG THE SAME LINES!!

 

[princemaazthefinal]

I was dissapointed with some of the Harry Potter movies too anyways, they had edited sooo many parts like someone above said, and added some nonsense in too.
Basically THEY SHOULD NOT MAKE A MOVIE IF THERE'S A STORY WRITTEN ALONG THE SAME LINES!!

yea they were eddited but still.........THEY WERE PRETTY COOL!!!! 8)

 

[VelaneDeBeaute]

oh nice!!!
how did u get it????

Jxt thought it might interest all the Hp fans here....
http://www.freewebs.com/ephemerisblack/ ... sdiary.htm
Sumthing u wont find easily... :wink:

NICE!

Prince thanx...and falcon...i was searching 4 sum HP stuff thats wen i did thought it was pretty cool..!!

I was dissapointed with some of the Harry Potter movies too anyways, they had edited sooo many parts like someone above said, and added some nonsense in too.
Basically THEY SHOULD NOT MAKE A MOVIE IF THERE'S A STORY WRITTEN ALONG THE SAME LINES!!

That was perhaps bcuz HP had dense stories...i reckon if the whole story of Order of pheonix was pictured it would hve been 3 movies of over 5 hrs each...! But if u dnt compare em 2 the books...they're quite nice...!

 

[arlery]

Definitely Harry Potter, because it's an original masterpiece. Twilight one the other hand; the whole love triangle is something I never got, and it's too popular of an idea in the paranormal romance genre. As for the movies, HP movies were amazing till part four, but part seven sure picked up the missing essence in part 5 and 6. As for twilight, the acting is so unreal. I really hate how Kristen Stewart is unable to portray emotions. She has the same stupid expression in almost all the scenes. I think 'The Host' is a much better example of Stephenie Meyer's writing capabilities as Twilight was such a huge disappointment.

 

[VelaneDeBeaute]

Yeah keep supporting HP..!

 

[aleenarahman]

Harry Potter 4ever!!!!!!!! :Yahoo!:

 

[maybeitwasnoone]

Prince thanx...and falcon...i was searching 4 sum HP stuff thats wen i did thought it was pretty cool..!!

I was dissapointed with some of the Harry Potter movies too anyways, they had edited sooo many parts like someone above said, and added some nonsense in too.
Basically THEY SHOULD NOT MAKE A MOVIE IF THERE'S A STORY WRITTEN ALONG THE SAME LINES!!

That was perhaps bcuz HP had dense stories...i reckon if the whole story of Order of pheonix was pictured it would hve been 3 movies of over 5 hrs each...! But if u dnt compare em 2 the books...they're quite nice...!

I wouldn't have minded it.
And maybe there's more people who wouldn't have minded it.
Though the movies are kinda dark, it keeps you on your toes.

 

[arlery]

Prince thanx...and falcon...i was searching 4 sum HP stuff thats wen i did thought it was pretty cool..!!

I was dissapointed with some of the Harry Potter movies too anyways, they had edited sooo many parts like someone above said, and added some nonsense in too.
Basically THEY SHOULD NOT MAKE A MOVIE IF THERE'S A STORY WRITTEN ALONG THE SAME LINES!!

That was perhaps bcuz HP had dense stories...i reckon if the whole story of Order of pheonix was pictured it would hve been 3 movies of over 5 hrs each...! But if u dnt compare em 2 the books...they're quite nice...!

I wouldn't have minded it.
And maybe there's more people who wouldn't have minded it.
Though the movies are kinda dark, it keeps you on your toes.

Yeah, but the only reason i cried on watching Sirius' death in part 5 was because I had read the scene and practically memorized it, so I could feel the emotions that they didn't portray.

 

[maybeitwasnoone]

JK Rowling has that amazing ability, portraying feelings through words.

ALL hail HER!!

 

[VelaneDeBeaute]

yeah Sirius's death took no more than 30 seconds...and that's why they'll kill fred, tonks and lupin brutally...filling all the feelings...im definately gonna cry even if the scene's not supposed 2 b emotional..!

 

[arlery]

I know right? I even cried when dobby died. I bet I'll shed buckets of tears for Fred, Lupin and Tonks and even for poor Snape. ='(

 

[VelaneDeBeaute]

Yeah i'll bring tubs anyway
i even cried while reading the novel
and was depressed 4 a whole week..!

 

[falcon678]

u had such a deep effect!!!!i had no idea there were ppl who were deppressed by HP7 book....

 

[VelaneDeBeaute]

u had such a deep effect!!!!i had no idea there were ppl who were deppressed by HP7 book....

Depressed..!
u R JOKING...I didnt eat anything the day i read HP7...bcuz i had been sooooo emotionally attached to the book...!!

 

[falcon678]

lolz :lol:
emotionally attached????
sheesh!!

 

[Xenarra]

yea um wid HP....the book and the movie are nearly the same
stephanie meyer could have done sumthing with the characters in the movie tho..she was picking gaspard ulile and emily browing for bella and edward coz she imagined them that way....but they wernt the perfect fit....the movie is kinda lame now XP it makes vampires look like wusses.....bram stoker would slaughter her!
harry potter is way coooler!

 

[maybeitwasnoone]

Speaking of vampires, anyone watches Vampire Diaries here?

 

[arlery]

I do and I've read all the books too, that is until Harper Collins decided to fire her from her own series because she wanted to end the series with Damon and Elena together.