Pakistan Studies, Islamiyat and Urdu: Post your doubts here!

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

Btw, did you write both successes and failures, in Question 3(c) ?

it doesnot matter i think :S because all had such reasons because of which they made attempts although i had studied marking scheme and wrote in seperate paragraphs.. you would get marks for that don't worry

 

[princess Anu]

yess

 

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

Okay, Same here.

yess

 

[princess Anu]

how about islamiat p2 ? how did it go?
also reply my above ques for fishing question if you attempted it..

 

[M.Omar]

Damn it!
My answer to that 1 (b) question in History, the one about why there were three attempts to revive islam, is wrong!
Apparently, we had to write about all three reformers in three separate paragraphs. -__-
But i wrote a general answer. :/

well,i did tell u abt the need to discuss all 3....................Listen in the simon commission point u discussed above,it must be remembered tht RTC,s were an entity among themselves and discussing tht the gulf was revealed in btw the muslims and hindus is to be attributed to RTC,s not simon commision so we could say it indirectly lead to developement of pak movement ....i wrote how opposition to these proposals were imp wht imp it showed and then told the result the of opposition of simon tht is Nehru report and the disagreement in them this meant little hindu cooperation ..concentrated 50 50 on imp of simon commision and also its opposition which was the other part...did not mention RTC,s as they r a seperate entity and another event.....wht do u think abt this

 

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

Islamiat p2, was my worst paper of all 4 of them.
What did you write about in Question 2, Communal Life or Individual Life?
And i didn't attempt that fishing question, i attempted 3,4,5

how about islamiat p2 ? how did it go?
also reply my above ques for fishing question if you attempted it..

 

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

I also did not mention RTC's. Neither Congress Rule, Neither Pakistan Resolution!
Right now, at home.. i am remembering all the points.
Over there, i wrote only some of these -.-
Ugh!

well,i did tell u abt the need to discuss all 3....................Listen in the simon commission point u discussed above,it must be remembered tht RTC,s were an entity among themselves and discussing tht the gulf was revealed in btw the muslims and hindus is to be attributed to RTC,s not simon commision so we could say it indirectly lead to developement of pak movement ....i wrote how opposition to these proposals were imp wht imp it showed and then told the result the of opposition of simon tht is Nehru report and the disagreement in them this meant little hindu cooperation ..concentrated 50 50 on imp of simon commision and also its opposition which was the other part...did not mention RTC,s as they r a seperate entity and another event.....wht do u think abt this

 

[M.Omar]

I also did not mention RTC's. Neither Congress Rule, Neither Pakistan Resolution!
Right now, at home.. i am remembering all the points.
Over there, i wrote only some of these -.-
Ugh!

do give me ur views abt my answer....can u

 

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

You had to discuss all three events and their significance in instilling in the Muslims a sense of a separate identity, as that was the main principle of the Pakistan Movement. Or Maybe we had to tell the clauses and all, i did not mention the clauses. We never know :/

well,i did tell u abt the need to discuss all 3....................Listen in the simon commission point u discussed above,it must be remembered tht RTC,s were an entity among themselves and discussing tht the gulf was revealed in btw the muslims and hindus is to be attributed to RTC,s not simon commision so we could say it indirectly lead to developement of pak movement ....i wrote how opposition to these proposals were imp wht imp it showed and then told the result the of opposition of simon tht is Nehru report and the disagreement in them this meant little hindu cooperation ..concentrated 50 50 on imp of simon commision and also its opposition which was the other part...did not mention RTC,s as they r a seperate entity and another event.....wht do u think abt this

 

[princess Anu]

Islamiat p2, was my worst paper of all 4 of them.
What did you write about in Question 2, Communal Life or Individual Life?
And i didn't attempt that fishing question, i attempted 3,4,5

Ohkay and same here. I am so stupid i attempted the wrong question of caliphs and got stuck. also in other questions i didnot even thought much just went on writing i was so scared because of lack of time :'(
I dont remember though but i conveyed about an individual's conduct in community like he should oppose evil, if he is a ruler he has to be kind , he should take care of orphans, poor and like that by quoting ahadis .. what do u wrote and what you think about my answer?

 

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

Your answer is alright. What was needed was a critical analysis of these three events. From the looks of it, you gave a good analysis of the Simon Commission.

do give me ur views abt my answer....can u

 

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

I am stupid too.
I had not studied the Eid-Ul-Fitr and Eid-Ul-Azha thing, had to write that answer by myself.
And i wrote about Communal Life.
Quoted the Hadis that were given in question 1 as i had not learned any! :/
You attempted the one about Hajj?

Ohkay and same here. I am so stupid i attempted the wrong questions of caliphs and got stuck. also in other questions i didnot even thought much just went on writing i was so scared because of lack of time :'(
I dont remember though but i conveyed about an individual's conduct in community like he should oppose evil, if he is a ruler he has to be kind , he should take care of orphans, poor and like that by quoting ahadis .. what do u wrote and what you think about my answer?

 

[Afnan shaukat]

I did a big blunder in Q2 of islamiyat p2 . Wrote about individual life instead of Muslim communal life

 

[princess Anu]

I am stupid too.
I had not studied the Eid-Ul-Fitr and Eid-Ul-Azha thing, had to write that answer by myself.
And i wrote about Communal Life.
Quoted the Hadis that were given in question 1 as i had not learned any! :/
You attempted the one about Hajj?

You are not stupid you attempted right one because you could write facts about it but the question about battles i attempted on same basis because i thought eid ul fitr and azha were not in book so i know less about them so went for the battles .. the battles were soo confusing although i studied them many times i hardly wrote about them for 1 page and half ..
like how about communal life? and Yes i did and created a mess in b part

 

[M.Omar]

You had to discuss all three events and their significance in instilling in the Muslims a sense of a separate identity, as that was the main principle of the Pakistan Movement. Or Maybe we had to tell the clauses and all, i did not mention the clauses. We never know :/

yup,i discussed all the abv points with the exception of rtc,s and i replaced it with nehru report which came as result of opposition to simon commision and the reaction of jinnah after nehru report and this stirred emotions among muslims and led to idea they cannot co-exist......(So i mean to say i replaced rtc,s with nehru report though my arguments did convey how this(NEHRU REPORT) led to development of pakistan movement) so i did explain wht the question asked..............kindly,reply to tell me ur views,thnx a bunch

 

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

Lol, How many will you get in it out of 10?

I did a big blunder in Q2 of islamiyat p2 . Wrote about individual life instead of Muslim communal life

 

[Afnan shaukat]

I did a big blunder in Q2 of islamiyat p2 . Wrote about individual life instead of Muslim communal life

 

[Nabeel.Ahmad]

I quoted the one about CHARITY.. every act is a charity one!
And explained it a bit.
Then quoted the one about Mercy.. One who shows mercy Allah will show mercy to him
And then finally, None of you believes until he wants for his brother what he wants for himself.
Quoted and explained these three!
How many will i get?

You are not stupid you attempted right one because you could write facts about it but the question about battles i attempted on same basis because i thought eid ul fitr and azha were not in book so i know less about them so went for the battles .. the battles were soo confusing although i studied them many times i hardly wrote about them for 1 page and half ..
like how about communal life? and Yes i did and created a mess in b part

 

[M.Omar]

Your answer is alright. What was needed was a critical analysis of these three events. From the looks of it, you gave a good analysis of the Simon Commission.

just read it,thnx totally relieved me.....A big thank u

 

[princess Anu]

lol you are asking me who is already scared about cie examiners.. i dont know
Allah knows best and he will give us the reward of our efforts so chill...