• We need your support!

    We are currently struggling to cover the operational costs of Xtremepapers, as a result we might have to shut this website down. Please donate if we have helped you and help make a difference in other students' lives!
    Click here to Donate Now (View Announcement)

BAN MUSIC CAMPAIGN - For Muslim brothers and sisters

Status
Not open for further replies.

N.M

Messages
685
Reaction score
10,915
Points
503
وَعِبَادُ الرَّحۡمٰنِ الَّذِيۡنَ يَمۡشُوۡنَ عَلَى الۡاَرۡضِ هَوۡنًا وَّاِذَا خَاطَبَهُمُ الۡجٰهِلُوۡنَ قَالُوۡا سَلٰمًا‏



And the servants of (Allah) Most Gracious are those who walk on the earth in humility, and when the ignorant address them, they say "Peace!" (63) Surah Furqan

This is all i will say "PEACE". I think i will just waste time explaining what some people can't understand....



p.s: plz watch the lecture by kemal al makki
 
Messages
8,393
Reaction score
9,461
Points
573
excuse me. i didnt say anything to u. u r the moderator and u better mind ur language. mind what u say to others
unique840: I'm really sorry but I think Nibz was pointing out some other thing, he wasn't giving stating that music is halaal or haram. :)
Just to clear up some arguments. I think he got offended as you forgot to read his post. :) Please don't mind anything.
It's Ramazan people, why argue? :D
 
Messages
729
Reaction score
477
Points
73
No one ever asked u to convince anyone about anything.PERIOD.
Plus i dare u to show me someone who listens to music alot and learns the Quran by-heart.
My cousin has passed away( May he rest in peace) . He was a Hafiz and you know what, he listened to lots of music too. In a day, when he went to madrassa he looked like a Qari, at the other time of the day, he dressed appeared completely differently. And he also became the Imam during Tarawih prayers. so, there's someone :\
 

badrobot14

XPRS Administrator
Messages
3,371
Reaction score
34,691
Points
523
No one ever asked u to convince anyone about anything.PERIOD.
Plus i dare u to show me someone who listens to music alot and learns the Quran by-heart.
Nah.. I think its actually possible for someone to listen to music and learn Quran.. Allah made the Quran extremely easy for zikr... What I think will be hard for the person, would be to have a connection with the Quran.. to cry in salah with it maybe. Allah knows best.
 
Messages
671
Reaction score
641
Points
103
Nah.. I think its actually possible for someone to listen to music and learn Quran.. Allah made the Quran extremely easy for zikr... What I think will be hard for the person, would be to have a connection with the Quran.. to cry in salah with it maybe. Allah knows best.
Listening is possible but like u said the connection is not.
Even by-hearting the Quran while listening to music alot isnt possible rite?
 
Messages
671
Reaction score
641
Points
103
My cousin has passed away( May he rest in peace) . He was a Hafiz and you know what, he listened to lots of music too. In a day, when he went to madrassa he looked like a Qari, at the other time of the day, he dressed appeared completely differently. And he also became the Imam during Tarawih prayers. so, there's someone :\
This is really strange!
Maybe there are people who can do that afterall.
 
Messages
760
Reaction score
4,956
Points
253
If something is not haram why would anyone want to stop it.
In the hadith when the prophet says that people will come after him will say that music is halal..that is an indication that they are wrong and that it is haram otherwise, the prophet Salla alaho alehe wa salam wouldnt have mentioned them.
Yeah...that's true but I think he meant the present songs some people even don't care that Music is Haram or Halal... :(... I was quiet addicted to nasheeds and I have reduced to minimum u know it takes time to leave...But our Beloved Prophet (SAW) said: that they will make music lawful...so u can see that many muslims listen to songs like all thoses hollywood, bollywood songs...and even they don't care...I have tried my best to reduced nasheeds how much I can....:)...And other than nasheeds I donot listen anything. only for 5-20 min...during ramadan I donot listen...during school days 5-8 min...I do not say that music is lawful...ofcourse :)
 
Messages
671
Reaction score
641
Points
103
Yeah...that's true but I think he meant the present songs some people even don't care that Music is Haram or Halal... :(... I was quiet addicted to nasheeds and I have reduced to minimum u know it takes time to leave...But our Beloved Prophet (SAW) said: that they will make music lawful...so u can see that many muslims listen to songs like all thoses hollywood, bollywood songs...and even they don't care...I have tried my best to reduced nasheeds how much I can....:)...And other than nasheeds I donot listen anything. only for 5-20 min...during ramadan I donot listen...during school days 5-8 min...I do not say that music is lawful...ofcourse :)
Thats the gud thing about u. U admitt music is nt halal and now u want to stop it =). I'm trying to stop listening to it too..Hopefully i can do that in the near future isa :D
 
Messages
760
Reaction score
4,956
Points
253
Thats the gud thing about u. U admitt music is nt halal and now u want to stop it =). I'm trying to stop listening to it too..Hopefully i can do that in the near future isa :D
Ofcourse..I never said it's halal :)...It means u also listen to nasheeds and trying to stop them...Actually I have seen many people they listen to songs and I've seen If u will ask them that how many surahs u know they will be knowin may be 2 or 3...If u will ask do u listen to nasheeds they will say no....They only listen to music and my school is full such students :) me and my friends are like me :)
 
Messages
671
Reaction score
641
Points
103
Ofcourse..I never said it's halal :)...It means u also listen to nasheeds and trying to stop them...Actually I have seen many people they listen to songs and I've seen If u will ask them that how many surahs u know they will be knowin may be 2 or 3...If u will ask do u listen to nasheeds they will say no....They only listen to music and my school is full such students :) me and my friends are like me :)
Exactly!
 

XPFMember

XPRS Moderator
Messages
4,555
Reaction score
13,290
Points
523
dude I 'm not sure . I not even a heavy listener of music! What I'm standing for is you cannot call Haraam what is not mentioned as Haraam! Do not accuse me! btw how can it be from Satan. Satan is chained in this month , right?? :/
And not always it contains offensive language. There are sometimes music which do not even have wordings!
AsSalamoAlaikum Wr Wb!

With due respect, I request you to check this out, plz: The End Of Music by Kamal el Makki

It'll just take you an hour. After Fajr Salah, you probably would read Quran and then sleep...try to take out an hour and lidten to this whole lecture...a humble request.

...and then come back and let me know if music is halal or haram.

Wassalam..
 
Messages
729
Reaction score
477
Points
73
AsSalamoAlaikum Wr Wb!

With due respect, I request you to check this out, plz: The End Of Music by Kamal el Makki

It'll just take you an hour. After Fajr Salah, you probably would read Quran and then sleep...try to take out an hour and lidten to this whole lecture...a humble request.

...and then come back and let me know if music is halal or haram.

Wassalam..
is this the one hour lecture?? sure I'll check it out. been looking for it.
btw I never said it was Halal.
thanks :)
 

XPFMember

XPRS Moderator
Messages
4,555
Reaction score
13,290
Points
523
My cousin has passed away( May he rest in peace) . He was a Hafiz and you know what, he listened to lots of music too. In a day, when he went to madrassa he looked like a Qari, at the other time of the day, he dressed appeared completely differently. And he also became the Imam during Tarawih prayers. so, there's someone :\
AsSalamoAlaikum Wr Wb...

I'd wanna say something here..

Forgive me, if you didnt mean in that sense at all...

If, and only if, you mean to say that he was so and so, and he used to do...that wont, in any way, make music halal....We are not to judge the laws of Islam by its people...! It's the Quran and Hadith...with which we are to see what's right, and what's wrong...

A man recklessly driving a BMW, has an accident or so...can we blame the car, or shall we blame the driver? Ofcourse, the driver...

So next time, we try to find out faults in a person who tells us something about the deen, we should think again....We shouldn't reallybe concerned if that person is doing it or not...cuz that isnt our headache...we should worry if 'we' are doing it or not..

Ya Allah, plz make us among the muttaqeen and saliheen ...aameen..
 
Messages
729
Reaction score
477
Points
73
AsSalamoAlaikum Wr Wb...

I'd wanna say something here..

Forgive me, if you didnt mean in that sense at all...

If, and only if, you mean to say that he was so and so, and he used to do...that wont, in any way, make music halal....We are not to judge the laws of Islam by its people...! It's the Quran and Hadith...with which we are to see what's right, and what's wrong...

A man recklessly driving a BMW, has an accident or so...can we blame the car, or shall we blame the driver? Ofcourse, the driver...

So next time, we try to find out faults in a person who tells us something about the deen, we should think again....We shouldn't reallybe concerned if that person is doing it or not...cuz that isnt our headache...we should worry if 'we' are doing it or not..

Ya Allah, plz make us among the muttaqeen and saliheen ...aameen..
of course you're right, but I was telling it in context. It was a reply to a post of someone who said someone can't listen to music and also read The Quran(even at different times) . So it was an answer to that. I am in no way saying music is halaal. :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top